Home > apologetics, church history, Creation, Young Earth > The Flat Earth Myth: The Greatest Urban Legend of History

The Flat Earth Myth: The Greatest Urban Legend of History

The following is an article I wrote a few years ago, before I started this blog.  The issue is still timely, a false idea so ingrained as to be thought true, that sometimes Christians unwittingly mention — as examples of Bible criticism-and-response — the idea that people used to believe the earth was flat.  So I’m re-posting it here for future reference.

A medieval history message board (early 2008) pondered the matter of the Flat Earth myth, wondering how much information the ancients and medieval men had, as well as where the myth started. Contrary to today’s popular opinion, medieval man, both educated and common, understood that the earth was round and had no cause to think otherwise. The ancient Greeks had determined the shape of the earth, and in 200 B.C. using their understanding of mathematics calculated the circumference of the earth at the equator to be about 24,500 miles. The Greek calculation also understood that one longitude degree was equal to about 70 nautical miles (very close to the actual number of 71 miles). Throughout the ancient world, and medieval times which continued the ancients’ classical understanding, the circle and sphere held symbolic spiritual significance in the idea of perfection. Aristotle’s cosmology included circles and spheres, and to medieval man it was quite natural that the earth, like those heavenly bodies, was also a sphere.

Scholarly history books also state the truth, as for instance Edward Grant’s ‘Physical Science in the Middle Ages’:

Contrary to popular contemporary misconception that prior to the discovery of America by Christopher Columbus the earth was thought to be flat, no flat-earthers of any consequence are known in the Latin West. Aristotle’s arguments for a spherical earth were so reasonable and sound that its truth was readily accepted.

Literature from the medieval period also reflects this thinking. Dante, one of the most popular authors of the time, described the accepted cosmology in his works, in which the Earth is a sphere. Yet today many public school textbooks, and thus the adults taught the myth, readily accept that common Europeans believed the earth was flat, and that the shape of the earth was some great controversial thing when Columbus “dared” to sail west. But consider the actual written records from Columbus’ day. The logs and other records indicate that the common sailors were greatly concerned about how far away they were from land and the uncertainty of it all, wondering if they would run out of provisions; sea-faring was hazardous enough in those days, and it was always best to stick to known routes close to familiar landmarks. No mention is made of the fear of falling off the earth, and sailors were among the lower, less-educated social class.

For Columbus’ voyage, the distance involved was the real issue. The ancient Greek calculation of 70 miles per longitude degree meant that India and Asia were extremely far west. Columbus had tried his own hand at the math, declaring that instead each longitude degree was only 50 miles, but he was laughed at and rejected by the expert sea-farers of the day, the Portugese, who knew their math and distances. Spain’s rulers, in an up and coming kingdom but with less experience, were more willing to accept Columbus’ calculations, and in good Providence — because there happened to be another continent in the middle — the gamble actually paid off in the long run.

Since both science and popular literature of the time affirmed the classical cosmology of the day, who were the “many Europeans” (we always hear about) who believed the Earth was flat? As another blogger points out in “No Wonder There Are Uproars About Textbooks,” the “many Europeans” must have been some unreached circumpolar people or pagans in the hills of Ireland or Lithuania. But medieval people lived in a community, interacting with each other and with their educated Lords and knights, and understood well enough their own culture if not their own science.  “In other words, a medieval person who thought the Earth was flat would be unfamiliar not only with the science of the day but with the popular literature based on it (in other words, completely culturally ignorant).”

So where did the flat earth myth originate? It started in the early-to-mid nineteenth century, with the Darwin evolutionists eager to find (or invent) reasons to discredit the Church and traditional Christian authority. After all, if you can get people to believe that, in those previous, oppressive days of the Catholic Church (the Middle Ages) the people were so ignorant and believed the world was flat, then you can also convince them that the Church and its followers are also wrong about other traditional views of the Bible: in this case, special recent creation by God instead of evolution. The idea was first introduced in a fictional context, with Washington Irving’s ‘History of the Life and Voyages of Christopher Columbus’ (1828). In this account, flat-earth churchmen oppose Columbus, saying he would fall off the edge of the earth if he tried to sail west. After Darwin published his ‘On the Origin of Species’ in 1859, two of his followers presented this flat-earth myth as actual history, in books that upheld Darwin against those “ignorant Christians”: John Draper’s ‘The History of the Conflict Between Religion and Science’ (1874), and Andrew Dickson White’s ‘A History of the Warfare of Science with Theology in Christendom’ (1896). The trend has continued ever since, and this false history is perpetuated in text books to this day.

Further reference:  The Wikipedia entry, Myth of the Flat Earth

  1. Steven Hayes
    December 21, 2012 at 10:13 am

    Thanks! Excellent refutation of yet another revision of history by evolutionary humanists in control of our bankrupt educational establishment.

  2. December 22, 2012 at 1:28 am

    Excellent. May the LORD use this post for people to find it to equip them. It’s ridiculous how many times I hear people bring this up during campus evangelism.

  3. December 24, 2012 at 9:30 am

    Thanks Steven and Jim. Yes, this urban legend refuses to die, as too many people just accept an idea they’ve heard (what is actually a myth) and don’t look into it further.

  1. December 22, 2012 at 4:11 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: