Challies’ 2017 Reading Challenge: Scripture’s Attributes and Importance
In doing the 2017 Challies reading challenge, I’ve been going through my inventory of various free and low-cost books I have acquired over the last few years. These include a free audio recording of Kevin DeYoung’s “Taking God at His Word,” a past selection from Christian Audio’s monthly free downloads (the Kindle version is currently on sale for $3.99); a recent Christian Audio free offer (The Passionate Preaching of Martyn Lloyd Jones, by Steven Lawson); and a Kindle book that was free at the time of its publication a few years ago, The Fallible Prophets of New Calvinism. From reading these three books, plus the latter part of Iain Murray’s The Forgotten Spurgeon, I notice one common theme, expressed in different ways: the importance of Scripture.
Kevin DeYoung, Taking God at His Word: I had occasionally read blog posts from DeYoung, but not any books from him yet. The reading style is easy and straight-forward, and the introduction gave me the impression of a too-easy, too-light book. Yet the chapters of the book – though for a general layperson audience — provide solid material, a good overview of the Attributes of Scripture. I especially like his acronym SCAN: Sufficiency of scripture, Clarity (or perspicuity), Authority, and Necessity. Four different groups of people show a weakness in one of these attributes: Sufficiency – the “Rank and file Christian;” Clarity – Post-Moderns; Authority – Liberal Christians; and Necessity – Atheists and Agnostics. DeYoung’s popular style relates important ideas and responses to criticism of specific scripture accounts with current-day analogies, including reference to popular fiction such as the characters from Star Wars and Lord of the Rings. A notable example here is the book of Jonah, which Jesus refers to in statements that make it clear that Jonah was not merely a nice, moral literary story, but refers to actual historical events.
Spurgeon and Martyn Lloyd Jones: The latter part of The Forgotten Spurgeon addresses the downgrade controversy and the issue at stake — the authority of the Bible and the attack from increasing liberalism/modernism. Lawson’s The Passionate Preaching of Martyn Lloyd Jones, in dealing with London during Lloyd Jones’ preaching ministry in the mid-20th century, serves as a type of sequel to the condition of churches in London, the result several decades after the downgrade controversy that had begun in the late 1880s.
The Fallible Prophets of New Calvinism focuses on a quite recent attack on scripture, this one especially concerned with the sufficiency of scripture. Specifically, this book is one of several from the last few years that address the error of fallible prophecy, promoted by Wayne Grudem. A detailed and informative book, it considers several scriptural passages and interacts with and responds to Grudem’s errors regarding Agabus as well as many other problems with Grudem’s handling of scripture. The New Calvinist continuationist view, with new revelation that is vague and unclear, “fallible prophecies,” considers scripture as insufficient in itself.
Hi Lynda,
I really enjoy your cogent blogging and your example of diligence in reading.
This idea of “fallible prophets” is new to me…especially in reference to Wayne Gruden whose systematic theology book appears to be widely praised.
Would you please give a few examples of what this notion of “fallible prophets” is and what it “looks like”?
Thanks!
Hi Robert,
They have defined a type of New Testament prophecy as something different from OT prophecy. Their key text is the prophecy of Agabus in the book of Acts, which they claim was not fulfilled in the specifics per what Agabus had said. Many have responded to the Agabus claim, including a detailed chapter in the book I read and mentioned in this post.
Here are a couple blog posts on this issue, from The Cripplegate blog a few years ago:
http://thecripplegate.com/five-dangers-of-fallible-prophecy/
and
http://thecripplegate.com/throwing-prophecy-under-the-agabus/